FolioQ5AnswerLast checked 22 Nov 2026
As at
Sun 22 Nov 2026
Entries
8
Not yet
9
Page seal 258A, 220°53′. Drawn from the SHA 256 of this page’s source text258A
Page seal258A, 220°53′

How do I put DMARC at reject without losing email?

Short answer. Move in steps and let your DMARC reports decide each one. Stay at p=none until every real sender passes aligned, then quarantine, then reject. The new standard, RFC 9989, suggests at least a month at each of the first two steps. If your staff post to mailing lists, it advises against reject; quarantine may be your end point.

What we have measured. Nothing yet; no domain has reached reject under our watch.1

What changed in 2026

DMARC was rewritten as RFC 9989 in May 2026. It replaced RFC 7489. Two changes matter for this question.

  • The pct tag is gone. It let owners apply a policy to a share of failing mail. RFC 9989 removed it, because experience showed it was usually not applied accurately unless set to 0 or 100 (appendix A.6). Many guides, including Microsoft's DMARC page updated in July 2026, still show pct. The tag is now registered as historic, so do not rely on receivers reading it.
  • A new t tag (test mode). t=y asks receivers to treat failing mail one level below the policy you publish. So p=reject; t=y asks for quarantine handling while you test. t=n, the default, applies the policy as written.

Steps you can do yourself, free

  1. Start at p=none with reports to your own domain.
    _dmarc.yourdomain   TXT   "v=DMARC1; p=none; rua=mailto:dmarc-reports@yourdomain"
  2. List every source in the reports.

    Each row shows a sending IP, a message count, and whether SPF and DKIM passed and aligned. Microsoft's guide names the classic problem: SPF passed but did not align, which means a real service is sending with its own return address.

  3. Fix each real sender

    by signing DKIM with your domain in that tool, or by setting its MAIL FROM to your domain. Keep SPF to one record and 10 lookups (RFC 7208).

  4. Wait for clean weeks, not clean days.

    Payroll, quarterly invoices and year end mail come from tools you forget. RFC 9989 suggests at least a month at p=none before the next step. Microsoft warns that report volume rises and falls with your own mail, for example during holidays.

  5. Move to quarantine.

    Either publish p=quarantine, or publish p=reject; t=y, which asks for the same quarantine handling. Watch again for a similar period.

  6. Move to reject

    when the failing traffic left in the reports is forgery or forwarding you can explain. Start with low volume subdomains and do the main domain last, as Microsoft advises.

  7. Keep reading reports after reject.

    A new tool added by a colleague next year will fail on day one.

When reject is the wrong end point

RFC 9989 says it plainly: domains that host users who might post to mailing lists should not publish p=reject. Lists that pass on a message without changing the From line make it fail DMARC at the next receiver. The result can be bounces and staff being unsubscribed from the list. The RFC also says receivers must not reject on p=reject alone, so even at reject the receiver makes the last call.

Options if this applies to you:

  • Stop at quarantine on the main domain.
  • Ask staff to post to public lists from a separate subdomain with its own, softer policy.
  • Keep reject for domains and subdomains used only by systems (invoicing, alerts), where no person posts to lists.

Forwarding

Forwarded mail often fails SPF, because the forwarder's server is not in your SPF. DKIM usually survives forwarding if the body is not changed. That is one more reason to sign every sender with DKIM, not only SPF. Gmail exempts forwarded and mailing list messages from its alignment requirement for bulk senders.

What it costs to have it done

Market prices and timings we found, read 22 Nov 2026:

SellerWhat it statesSource
O365HQ450 USD per domain plus a 950 USD tenant fee, p=none to reject in about 4 monitored weeksS24, page reread
DMARC Report managed tierA fixed one time price per domain, given on request; enforcement within 90 days in writingS23, search result 22 Nov 2026, not yet opened2
Valimail45 day median to enforcement; 87 percent achieve and keep p=rejectS22, read 22 Nov 2026

Marsadel's own price. Firm's own prices, Tier 1 list, US dollars. At launch every job runs in runbook mode: AI agents read your reports, write each step for you and test the result. You, or whoever runs your website, apply each step; we do not log in to your systems. A second AI model and a named reviewer will check the work.3

  • Mail Enforcement alone, for a domain already at p=none with 14 days of reports: 120 USD at launch, where you apply each change from our written steps. Full price, once we can make the changes ourselves: 150 USD.
  • Full Domain and Mail Gap Closure, from any starting state to reject: 312 USD at launch. Full price: 390 USD.
  • Through an agency or IT firm (wholesale): at launch 76 USD and 200 USD; full price 95 USD and 250 USD.

Our ramp, and why it is slower. About 8 weeks from the start of Stage A to reject for a full Domain and Mail Gap Closure order: 72 hours of alignment work, 14 clean report days, quarantine, then 42 more days, the last 30 of them with mail from senders you have not approved under 1 percent. For Mail Enforcement alone, on a domain that already has 14 days of clean reports when you order, quarantine can be the first step and reject comes 42 days later, about 6 weeks. That is slower than the 4 week and 45 day figures above. We wait for 30 quiet days so that a rare sender shows up before it bounces. Each step needs your written approval. A sender that still fails holds the ramp with a written reason. If the reports show list traffic of the kind RFC 9989 warns about, the record stops at the policy the data allows, and says why.

The 42 day step is our own design. Red Sift says quarantine to reject typically takes 6 to 8 weeks; DuoCircle suggests under 1 percent unknown traffic for 30 days before reject, and gives 30 to 90 days from quarantine to reject (both read 22 Nov 2026).

Not on sale yet. Mail Enforcement opens after its quality test (target Fri 18 Dec 2026), once our company and checkout are live.

Not yet: Stage B Bench passed and sealed; target Fri 18 Dec 2026, first Mail Enforcement sale Mon 21 Dec 2026. Until then this unit is not on sale.4, 5, 6

Details: Mail Enforcement and Domain and Mail Gap Closure.

How to check it worked

Look up _dmarc.yourdomain and confirm the policy. In the next aggregate reports, your own sources should pass with disposition none, and forged sources should show quarantine or reject. Send a test from each tool you use and read the headers for dmarc=pass.

Facts on this page

FactSourceRead
RFC 9989, May 2026, obsoletes RFC 7489; pct removed (appendix A.6); t tag defined (section 4.7); at least a month at p=none then quarantine; mailing list warning (section 7.4); general purpose mail domains should not publish p=reject (appendix C.6); receivers must not reject solely on p=reject (section 8)datatracker.ietf.org/doc/rfc9989/22 Nov 2026
Gradual rollout, subdomains first, parent last; pct still shown; report volume varies; SPF pass but not aligned pattern; forwarding and DKIMlearn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-office-365/email-authentication-dmarc-configure (updated July 2026)22 Nov 2026
Gmail exempts forwarded and mailing list messages from bulk sender alignmentsupport.google.com/a/answer/14229414 (S14)22 Nov 2026
SPF single record and 10 lookup limitdatatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc720822 Nov 2026
Market prices and timingsValimail www.valimail.com/organization-enterprise/ (read 22 Nov 2026); DMARC Report dmarcreport.com/managed-compliance/ (search result 22 Nov 2026, not yet opened2); O365HQ o365hq.com/services/dmarc-dkim-spf-email-authentication (read 22 Nov 2026)22 Nov 2026
Quarantine to reject typically 6 to 8 weeksredsift.com/blog/us-dmarc-adoption-report (S28)22 Nov 2026
Under 1 percent unknown traffic for 30 days before reject; 30 to 90 days from quarantine to rejectwww.duocircle.com/email-security/10-steps-to-achieve-dmarc-reject-policy-readiness (S28)22 Nov 2026

Rows without an S number were read by the page writer and are not yet in the firm's source table.7

Questions people ask next

Should I still use pct=10, pct=50 and so on? Under RFC 9989 the tag no longer exists, so receivers that follow it ignore the value. Use t=y for a test step instead. Some older receivers may still read pct.

How do I know a failing source is forgery and not mine? Take the sending IP from the report and look up who holds it. If it belongs to a provider you use, it is probably yours and misconfigured. If you cannot tie it to any tool, treat it as forgery and keep it in the list for the next review.

What if a real sender cannot sign with my domain? Move that sender to a subdomain with its own DMARC record and policy, so it does not hold back the main domain. Microsoft's guide describes this route.

How long should I stay at quarantine? RFC 9989 suggests a period similar to your p=none period, at least a month, then comparing results. Our own ramp uses 42 days.

If I order, do you train AI models on my data? No, unless you tick a consent box that allows it.


Written by AI agents and checked against the sources above. Last checked 22 Nov 2026. No named human has reviewed this page yet.8 No partner is signed in any country yet.9

Not yet in place9

Nothing is on sale yet; each numbered mark on this page points to a condition below. Every condition, with its state, is on the status board.

  1. 1first reject with real traffic on an own domain or a client domain, with dates and n; earliest about 22 Jan 2027 on an own domain with traffic, otherwise about 12 Mar 2027 from the first expected orders
  2. 2page read in full
  3. 3second model vendor connected; two contracted reviewers, target Mon 30 Nov 2026
  4. 4Stage B Bench passed and sealed; target Fri 18 Dec 2026, first Mail Enforcement sale Mon 21 Dec 2026. Until then this unit is not on sale.
  5. 5company formed and checkout live
  6. 6Stage B ramp and acceptance reviewed against RFC 9989 sections 7.4 and C.6 before the gate
  7. 7each such row added to the plan source table with an S number and status
  8. 8named human reviewer under contract
  9. 9first partner agreements signed

Each item is also marked where it stands on this page.